Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

MPPR & Implications on Reimbursement

Alliance Corporate Compliance Officer Tiffany Warden and APTA Washington Board Member Mark Bouma join the podcast to discuss the implications of recent changes to Medicare’s and commercial insurance payers’ policies regarding Multiple Procedure Payment Reduction (MPPR). Key topics discussed: Recent changes to Medicare’s MPPR How commercial payers are reducing their reimbursement to match What practice owners should do in the face of these reductions
Alliance Physical Therapy Partners: 00:03 You’re listening to the PT Leadership Podcast, where outpatient physical therapy leaders come to share their insights with your host, Richard Leaver. Richard Leaver: 00:16 Welcome back to another podcast of PT Leadership Series. I am excited to welcome two guests on this episode where we’re going to talk about the really exciting topic of MPPR. But before we get into the what it is and the uh everything about it, I’d love to perhaps our guests to introduce themselves, and Mark Bauma and Tiffany Warden. So Tiffany, I know you’re a frequent guest on the podcast, but for those that perhaps haven’t heard any of the podcasts, perhaps if you’d like to introduce yourself first. Tiffany Warden: 00:53 My name is Tiffany Warden, and I’m the corporate compliance officer for Alliance Physical Therapy Partners. I’ve been with the company uh for 14 years. Richard Leaver: 01:01 14, gosh. That’s uh Yeah, that’s surprised time how time flies. Hey. And then uh Mark, Mark and I, just full disclosure, actually worked together about a decade ago. Uh obviously, Mark, you get younger every day, and I seem to get older, but uh love perhaps for the listeners to learn about you. Mark Bouma: 01:22 Yeah, I’m a uh physical therapist and uh owner at uh Lake Washington Physical Therapy in Seattle. Uh my wife and I own two two locations of Lake Washington Physical Therapy, and then I’ve also been um active on the board of um uh APTA Washington um as well as uh the MPPR task force for uh APTA Washington over the last uh last few months. Um so Yeah, I’ve been a PT for about 20 years. Richard Leaver: 01:50 Fantastic. And I I didn’t realize there was a task force per se. I uh that’s equivalent to probably just going out and smacking your head against the wall almost. So uh thank you for I don’t know if you volunteered for it, but thank you for participating in that at least anyway. So Yeah. Um so MPPR, it’s been around for quite a while. Uh love perhaps Tiffany, for you to tell us a little bit about what MPPR is, the what the abbreviation stands for, and perhaps a little bit of background about it before we kind of dive into the impact on the outpatient therapy. Tiffany Warden: 02:27 Yeah, MPPR has been around since roughly 2011-2012. And basically, it stands for multiple procedure payment reduction. And the basic idea is that when multiple therapy services are provided to the same patient on the same day, Medicare will pay the full allowed amount for the service with the highest practice expense value and reduces the practice expense portion on any subsequent services uh delivered on that day. Uh originally it was introduced as a uh, I believe it was a 25% reduction, but about a year later, Congress actually increased that to a 50% reduction on the practice expense portion, which leads us to where we are today. Richard Leaver: 03:11 Yes, uh, of course they increased the reduction by why we wouldn’t we’ll dive into that in implication a little bit later, but but um can we just talk about the practice expense size? I think there’s a little bit of perhaps confusion around this. And what did they actually reduce? They didn’t reduce the the total amount, did they? Um, and this really goes into perhaps how Medicare CMS uh actually uh calculates the value of a unit. But perhaps you can talk about what what what it is specifically that they’re reducing, Tiffany. Tiffany Warden: 03:49 Okay. Yeah, so the practice expense is just a portion of what Medicare allows for a specific for reimbursement on a specific CPT code. And the practice expense uh uh reflects exactly what it says it does, the expense that the practice incurs for providing the services, the overhead and and the like. Um the argument is that when you deliver multiple services on the same day, it doesn’t cost you 100% for delivering an additional unit. Um, you know, obviously we would argue otherwise because the rent is still due, the power still has to stay on, the people still have to be paid, all of these things still have to happen at 100%. But they’re thinking from an efficiency standpoint, they can achieve efficiency on the budgetary side by reducing that because we’re not incurring a new bill when in reality it’s just an extension of the bills that were already paid with no reduction on our end. Richard Leaver: 04:45 Now, now, Mark, what um what common things do they supposedly say that are uh part of this this practice expense? Um because I think as Tiffany says, there’s definitely I think there’s some validity with it to a certain extent, and we can argue about you know how how valid and how much. But what types of things are they saying that perhaps are are part of this practice expense component? Mark Bouma: 05:16 Yeah, this is, I mean, this has been, I guess to to even set the table on this, a couple of years ago, I I didn’t know about, I mean, I’ve heard of MPPR, but in the last last six months I’ve kind of got thrown into the into the ringer. And um, there’s so much to this. I mean, it’s and I still it’s difficult for me to wrap my mind around how all these how practice expenses is um calculated and and the the actual um arithmetic on on what that looks like, even what CMS is using, is is really hard to hard to actually get a plain and simple um understanding of. But there’s it comes down to direct and indirect. There’s there’s two silos of practice expense. And the direct uh practice expense really is is for your support staff, not not your PTs, but your support staff greeting the patient, prepping the room, cleaning the rooms, things like that. Um, supplies like gloves, lotion, theraband, things like that. And then also just the equipment, the tables you’re using, the treadmills, the bikes, things like that. So that goes into like the direct expense, practice expense portion. And then the indirect is more of the uh the front desk, the time you spend scheduling, the billing, the rent, the utilities, the EMR, the accounting, legal, those types of things. Um, and that that tends to be um more spread out across all of them, but the direct um so this is this is the it comes down to this is the crux of the issue is um there’s a lot of things that um are not duplicative um, you know, in in in terms of how we provide physical therapy. Every single code uses, you know, the table still, uses support staff still, uses um more theraband, more cleaning supplies. I mean, we’re cleaning equipment from from every code that we’re going through throughout the treatment. So um the fact that it is, that they they say is it’s duplicative, is is really not applicable with how physical therapy is is delivered. And you have to remember in a code, practice expense is it varies, but is about 50% of the overall what we’re reimbursed in in a code, and then professional work is you know, the work of the clinician is is about 50%, and then there’s about 1% in there, a small little sliver for malpractice. Um, so it ends up being about roughly half of what we’re we’re paid is is siloed into the practice expense. Richard Leaver: 07:43 What I find interesting is you know the Congress brought this in after the fact way they’d been paying us. So this wasn’t from the beginning, was it? It was at some point somebody thought at Congress, oh, we’re probably actually spending too much money. Let’s think of a way we can actually claim back some of that money. And oh, well, let’s let’s just make an assumption that uh after the first 15 minutes of eight to 15 minutes of time, then all of a sudden these expenses suddenly reduce. And so let’s just take a percentage haircut um uh and you know, somewhat arbitrary. And then a year later they think, oh, we’ve got to save some more money. Uh let’s take a bigger haircut because this is a good idea. Um, and uh it as Tiffany, you say, it kind of jumped from 20, 25% to 50% of the very next year. The very next year, Yeah. So obviously they had a bad year financially, and uh uh the uh perhaps the politicians needed an additional pay raise or something, who knows? Um what’s funny, I know we’re jumping ahead a little bit with this, but um I used the same argument back to a commercial payer in North Carolina, and I said, well, you know, if you are reducing our practice expense, then how about you reduce the overall expense or the charge you have for your members if you actually have family members on the same plan? Because theoretically, you know, if you have an individual on the plan, then then the your expense would be X amount. And for every family member you join on that plan, then technically it’s actually less work for you to actually do to sign that member up or their family members up. Um you can imagine that uh that didn’t actually get very far that that argument. I thought it was pretty hilarious to be honest. Um okay, so it’s a component of the charge, um, quite a significant component uh overall. Um and uh what is the approximate perhaps dollar impact um by having this NPPR component? Do we have any uh clear understanding of perhaps what what that the the financial cost has been? Um I appreciate there’s probably uh variance geographically and some other factors, but but in a ballpark way uh wise, what do we think has been the impact? Tiffany Warden: 10:33 Well the the variance it also is tied to the type of code that you use. So, I mean, obviously you have CPT codes that are uh reimbursed at different rates, so um you’re not always going to get the same number. But I think what I’ve observed is anywhere between eight and fifteen dollars per claim, depending on how that claim is coded overall. Richard Leaver: 10:57 Yeah, what have you found, Mark? Um, I know it’s probably in the beginning, as you say, probably didn’t take any notice or weren’t really aware of the cost. But um what what what have you um kind of thought as it pertains to the cost to the clinic? Mark Bouma: 11:15 Yeah, well, with the most recent battle we’ve had in Washington State, um it it was uh factored to be between 15 to 20 percent uh reduction in payment, um, which you know if you look at what the operating uh the margins are for most PT clinics uh in general, um that that that alone will put you um really close to what the the cost is to deliver a visit in and of itself. So um I don’t think it you don’t have to do very complex math to figure out that something will have to give or would have to give if if if the MPPR were to go through with um certain commercial pairs. Richard Leaver: 11:58 Yes. Um when uh a large commercial payer in Michigan implemented this, it impacted actually 17% uh for Alliance. And I think that number was really pretty much identical for uh for other uh providers as well. So this kind of idea between 15 and 20, I think, is is right on the money. Um and as you say, Tiffany, I think it depends, the the percentage impact really depends on the number of units charged, doesn’t it, as well and the type of units, but uh quite considerably. But bottom line is this isn’t just an haircut of one or two percent off your reimbursement. This is this is really just slashing at it. And as you say, Mark, this is really having a profound impact on on what has been a kind of diminishing margin anyway to the business due to a to inflationary pressures and and reimbursement challenges. So this was kind of more than just a uh one nail in the coffin, this was a half a dozen, if not a dozen nails in the coffin, wasn’t it? Speaker 3: 13:02 Yeah, Yeah. Yes. Um now we’ve talked a little bit about the flaws of MPPR, um, but I think there’s some some more to understand about this perhaps. Um the first off is this concept that um it’s an arbitrary number, isn’t it? Richard Leaver: 13:30 And uh I don’t think anyone has actually sat down ever to actually calculate what is the appropriate production for practice expense. Am I correct in saying that? Tiffany Warden: 13:50 Yes. Mark Bouma: 13:52 Yeah, and and also, I mean, uh why wouldn’t it change from year to year, from quarter to quarter? From I mean, that’s the other thing. If you’re if you’re gonna calculate it, um you know, it it should it should be a a moving target for the cost of all the things that are listed under direct and indirect practice expense. Richard Leaver: 14:11 Yes, I think for equipment, for instance, the cost of equipment, I don’t think many of those items that we use have actually been updated for many years. In fact, uh I don’t think a lot of equipment that we use now uh exists now that didn’t 10, 20 years ago has even been included in uh which is just one of many examples, isn’t it, with regards to practice expense. And the last point I think um talking about MPPR and the calculation of it and how it’s calculated, um, it can impact multidisciplinary treatment the same day, can’t it? I think people don’t necessarily understand that. Um so I remember working in a hospital when you had OT and speech on the same day, you just get kind of uh hit left, right, and center, don’t you? Because it’s it almost combines the the impact uh as it pertains to multidisciplinary rehab care, yes. Mark Bouma: 15:13 Yeah, that’s very true. And that that’s something that uh you know we haven’t mentioned that this this is at least in in recently in in Washington, I mean this this change was affecting OT and speech and and among other ancillary providers, and and um you know it that that’s a really good point. I didn’t think of that with with uh patients that are seeing different different types of disciplines all on the same day. Um Yeah, you you wouldn’t want to be the the the last the last provider seeing that patient. Richard Leaver: 15:43 That’s right. Tiffany Warden: 15:46 Take the biggest hit. Richard Leaver: 15:49 That’s absolutely true. So um commercial payers, they often say that they follow Medicare uh guidelines, which in itself is really quite hysterical. Um and perhaps Tiffany, perhaps before we kind of talk specifically about MPPR, just the concept of commercial payers saying that they follow Medicare. Um can you perhaps give me um a little bit of background as to what they actually do follow and perhaps uh what they uh perhaps uh selectively um implement and then don’t implement, perhaps. Tiffany Warden: 16:29 Right. So I mean it’s basically it’s dealer’s choice with them. They’re going to say, well, we’re going to align ourselves with Medicare policy, generally speaking, but they don’t to the letter follow Medicare policy. So sometimes, no, not sometimes, all the times, it is up to the provider to actually do the research to say, okay, well, are you talking about a unit calculation methodology? Are you talking about um a local coverage determination, a national coverage determination? Are you talking about an MUE? Are you talking about um uh signatures on plans of care, referrals, uh medical necessity, documentation, progress note frequency, et cetera, et cetera. So they never really say, oh, we’re gonna follow just Medicare to the T. They’ll pick and choose what is beneficial, usually financially. Um, and then they will implement those, but leave, but leave any kind of rule out that doesn’t really touch them on the financial level. And it’s pretty concerning. It’s pretty concerning. They’re working, I guess, in the same vein that Congress was with these reductions with uh to to balance a budget, et cetera, et cetera. They’re not really balancing a budget like Congress was, they’re balancing their own pocketbook. And we think um, you know, we’re they’re doing it on the backs of providers, PT and in in OT and speech, especially, but they’re doing it on the backs of all the providers. And it’s really not to balance a budget, it’s to increase a bottom line, which is a far different goal than what has to be achieved uh at the congressional level. Richard Leaver: 18:00 You’re such a cynic, Tiffany. I can’t imagine that commercial payers aren’t trying to balance their their budgets. You know, they run on such a small margin and uh that uh anyway. Tiffany Warden: 18:12 I mean, we we’re talking about MPPR, but I mean we’ve got commercial payers that introduced a 2% sequestration uh cut. What are they doing? How are they what are they sequestring? What what what what are they doing? Explain that. Richard Leaver: 18:28 Great question. I mean if Mark wants to answer that one, probably not. Mark Bouma: 18:31 Well, there’s I mean, what I would say to to the it’s just it’s comical, really. I mean, there there’s a there’s an insurance company starts with a U, ends with uh knighted. Um that uh you know, quarter three, if you’ve followed like with their profits for quarter three, it’s it’s above four billion dollars in in one quarter uh of profit. That’s not just gross revenue. And you know, I I don’t so some of the insurance companies, um, depending on how they’re categorized as a company, they they don’t share, you know, their their profit um, you know, plain and clear, but it’s the these these these companies are not hurting at all. And and like you said, Tiffany, it’s it and and and Richard, it is they’re they’re pulling it out of the providers um from what they’re paying the providers, and and uh it’s just it’s it’s gone on so so far. It’s just it’s they’re taking this to the to the end degree, and I think that at some point we we’re getting closer to a breaking point where um what is insurance really worth anymore? Um, and and how many actual providers are going to actually be insurance-based providers. Um Tiffany Warden: 19:41 I agree. I think we’re very close to that tipping point. Alliance Physical Therapy Partners: 19:48 The foundation for the whole body is your feet, and more people than you might think are living with persistent foot, knee, hip, or even back pain that all begin with an unbalanced foundation. BioCorrect Custom Foot orthotics correct these imbalances for a better supportive foundation, achieving pain reduction benefits that perfectly complement physical therapy plans of care. With solutions from everyday use to sports-specific performance, BioCorrect can handle any need. Learn more about how BioCorrect can help you or your patients by reaching out to the team at BioCorrect.com. Richard Leaver: 20:29 Well, let’s kind of pull ourselves back out of the weeds perhaps a little bit and and not depress ourselves too much. Uh but um getting back to kind of MPPR. So Medicare obviously did it uh 2013. Uh, actually, I’m surprised that the commercial world’s taken this long, 13 years or 10 years, to actually um go down this road. But they they’ve they’ve seen the light, shall we say, and they’re jumping on the same bandwagon, aren’t they, Mark? So um obviously it’s not specific just to one state. But Mark, can you perhaps give us a little bit of information as pertains to the the commercial world and their what they’re uh what they’ve been looking at and doing perhaps in the last two, three years, perhaps as it pertains to MPPR. Mark Bouma: 21:18 Yeah, I mean I think that’s um it’s just it’s just another trigger that they’re trying to pull. And from from what we found in Washington State Um is uh this time last year, uh the same insurance company we we battled this just recently, this last few months, um they uh issued a going along with the CMS rules, they issued a payment policy memo out to all providers saying that they are going to follow um the eight minute rule um instead of the midpoint rule. And so that that’s how they’re going to um start to to categorize or look at coding from now on. And you know, our our APT of Washington Association kind of jumped all over that because that that actually would in some ways be more impactful than you know in terms of cost um and what we in changing our model, turning it upside down completely in Washington of how we how we can even care for these patients with uh um PTAIDs and supervision and length of appointments and whatnot. So um, you know, we we battled them then and they admitted they were like, oh, that’s a mistake, we shouldn’t have done that. It’s it’s not they they backtracked like it was an error. But I think what they were doing is they were testing the waters to see, you know, what type of a response they were going to get. Because um, from some of the um people I’ve talked to throughout our task force that you know are involved with contracts for large um NPT or in hospital-based uh companies, you know, they will try things. Insurance companies will try things, and if if there’s not enough volume and of of squeaky wheels and complaints, they’re gonna keep, they’re they’ll just do it. You know, but it it really comes down to the the volume of, and it’s not just five people being really loud, it’s it’s thousands of people and not just not just providers, because honestly, they could care less about providers. Um we’re at the bottom of the to me, I think we’re at the bottom of the food chain in terms of you know their ear actually listening to it’s the subscribers, and even more so, it’s the um, it’s like the Amazons, it’s the Starbucks, it’s the Microsoft’s, the the the large companies that actually choose to use Premera to provide healthcare for the members. So when those HR departments start to hear, like, wow, you know, we’re paying 20% more for premiums this year to you. Um, and wow, you’re what you’re paying for um to some of your providers and maybe potentially the access to to care for a lot of our our employees is going to drop, then that that that becomes concerning. And and that was really, you know, one of the leverage points we used in Washington was working through the employers and uh the HR departments. Yeah, so that’s it. Richard Leaver: 24:15 I love the fact that they they uh as you say, they they put out a a payment policy memo. It’s always a memo, isn’t it? That goes out and um you know they never they never make it uh obvious or they never widely perhaps uh um distribute the not the the the information to a point where it’s it’s clear, it’s kind of tucked in behind something or in a month a quarterly bulletin or something, isn’t it? Mark Bouma: 24:44 It was it was literally I would not have seen it. I mean, and I would and so many of us, but but a uh a billing company for a local private practice PT company who’s who is like on top of it found it like as an update, and it was it’s in the it was deep in the the the insurance company’s website um as an announcement and that that officially I guess satisfies the requirement to inform all providers, you know, there’s no no piece of paper that comes in the mail, no personal email from your provider relations specialist, nothing like that. It’s just uh you know a unilateral decision. Richard Leaver: 25:23 That’s right. Yeah. So what are the key arguments that the commercial payers are using to implement or try to implement MPPR? You know, some states, commercial payers have actually uh just uh steamrolled over providers and just gone ahead and done it. Um thankfully, actually, there have been a number of states where, based off advocacy from uh not only clinicians, patients, employers, etc., it has either temporarily been um uh stopped or actually permanently no longer being considered, which is fantastic. But um you know what arguments have have been put forwards uh as it pertains to the reasoning of why um the commercial payers would go down this road when we know that MPPR in itself is is really a flawed um calculation at the very least. Mark Bouma: 26:27 Yeah. Um, you know, I think the the argument is that it’s going to save. I mean, this is what what pro let me just share this. We we we were able to obtain um communication they sent to the members, and they said that they were going to continue to pay physical therapists in full. And you know, really what’s misleading about that is they’re they’re they’re going to continue paying the the work, uh professional work aspect of the code. Um, so they’re going to pay us, but they’re not going to pay the the practice expense, which they’re not going to share with the member or the subscriber. They don’t really care about that. Um and then the other argument that um that that really the the insurance company was sharing with uh the members is that um the policy will prevent duplicate charges from being added to their bill. In a way that it almost sounds like we’ve been billing duplicate charges the entire time, and now they’re actually going to correct a wrong, you know, um, which also is highly misleading and is certainly not not what’s going on. And the third thing uh that they uh they said that um members will see their out-of-pocket costs go down, and so those three um messages were all sent to any of the um insurance members or subscribers for this insurance company um directly to the uh to to after they they filed the complaints. And and and that’s really what uh again for us um as a as a state association, we went after those and said, you know, and this is where we got the office of the insurance commissioner involved, um, that this is these are false. And there’s way more to this than than these claims. Richard Leaver: 28:20 Yes, there’s been absolutely no demonstrated connection, has there, between MPPR savings and lower premiums. So um, you know, they’re not passing on any of these savings. And um, you know, to to give an idea of scale, the Alliance is certainly not one of the, it’s one of the larger providers in Michigan, certainly nowhere near the largest. And um, when a commercial player implemented this, this had an impact um of well over half a million dollars a year, just this one change. Um and uh, you know, there’s no way of making that back up. It’s just uh complete loss of revenue and then drops uh directly to profitability of the clinics. Um so uh you know it’s uh the members are not getting this saving drop-through to them. It’s purely being stuck within the system. I think the the thing that the first argument they use, um which reminds me of kind of uh um what I was told as a child in a minute, I’ll kind of reiterate that. But the the their first argument, Medicare does it, so they establish the precedent. So we can obviously do it, and that justifies it in itself. It’s like my mother used to say, you know, if somebody told you to to run off a cliff, would you do it? Um and uh that that’s just such a poor perspective to take, isn’t it? In fact, in fact, it’s it’s it’s so simple-minded. Well, he did it or she did it, so why can’t I? And um and they stuck to that and they continue to stick to that, even though they know it’s a flawed concept. Tiffany Warden: 30:11 Right. Right. And they give reasoning that just like like we just discussed, it just doesn’t make sense. There are no savings passed on. This is a this is a bottom line issue, especially if you look at uh the last two states. Well, the one, the state that’s coming up that’s implementing MPPR, and the state that just implemented MPPR last year that we discussed, both had significant financial difficulties and large losses, uh, had significant uh litigation that they were involved in for various issues. And so these cuts come at a time to where it’s fairly obvious what the reasoning um for them is. But but the other part of that too is Medicare, Medicare may establish a precedent for MPPR and an explanation. And we’ve talked about that, right? We’ve said this was to balance the budget, this was to do A, B, and C. Well, since then, there are certain pieces of legislation that have timed out that were tied to these budget cuts. They’re no longer there. So the question has to be asked. Number one, if the problem that these cuts were meant to help solve have been solved, why is the reduction still there? Number one. And number two, how are you tying, uh, how does a how does a commercial uh provider or payer explain their reasoning for the the implementation of these things, not just MPPR, but really any reduction down the line. Again, the sequestration one just gets me every time. There is no tie between sequestration and a private company. There is a tie between sequestration and Medicare. So, so if Medicare, like I said, may establish the precedent for doing so, but I don’t think that that alleviates these commercial companies uh from the burden of explaining to providers, of explaining to beneficiaries, shareholders, etc., um, why they are implementing some of these same measures, especially at a time when when Congress is going to be taking a look at this again to see whether or not it’s even necessary anymore, whether or not it needs to be changed. The Recover Act, what I’m specifically referring to. So I I find the timing of it all interesting. I find the impetus of um the uh the implementation of MPPR in the last couple of states very suspect. Uh, but I I don’t I don’t think it’s tied to balancing a budget at all. I think it’s tied to bottom line. Richard Leaver: 32:32 Yes, uh to to kind of close the loop here. Um obviously uh Alliance and many other entities uh communicated multiple times with with these commercial players, uh not only in Michigan, but also North Carolina, etc. And um after we kind of pushed back on this idea, well, Medicare does it, so we should do it. Um, then they actually came and they were somewhat honest and they said that they described NPPR as a cost management affordability initiative, you know, um, cost management perhaps for themselves. Uh, they didn’t say it was for themselves, but essentially that’s what it was. Um, but then they would decline to quantify the savings, the premium benefit um uh associated with that. So you know there is no way were they going to give information that, okay, this is perceived as a affordability initiative. Um, and then we push them on, okay. Well, uh, what’s going to be the impact on the premiums for the for the members? And uh, like you say, Yeah, your premiums are still gonna go up by 15-20 percent. Um and surprise, surprise, we’ll actually either won’t have losses next year as a commercial pair or actually we’ll have record profits, depending on which which pair it is. Anyway, um I think the last bit is this isn’t going away. Okay, there’s a constant pull push. Uh you know, payers um you know want to control, uh, continue to perhaps either in real or relative terms reduce reimbursement for for therapy services. And we’ve got to push back. And as I say, certain states where they’ve introduced the idea of implementing MPPPI and also other other cost reduction initiatives, um, I call it initiative, um, there’s been success with regards to getting them to at least reconsider it. And I think Washington has done a Great job, and thank you, Mark, as part of that task force. So love to perhaps tell the listeners you know how the task force um went about pushing back on the particular commercial pair in Washington. Because I think it was very similar to how other uh people have done it in other states. But but you know, when this happens again, uh, what can we do? What should we do? Mark Bouma: 35:11 Yeah, I think um that’s a great question. And this is something I think that um the listeners out there um, you know, know that they’re you’re up against a battle if you’re in a state that is is looking to implement this, but but persistence and organization and getting behind an association that um you know has has engaged members is is really really critical. So um I’m the I’m the chair of the um MPPR task force in Washington, and you know, we we learned about this um uh MPPR uh policy change in September, early September. It was going to go into effect December 4th. Um so we immediately realized with APTA Washington we needed to to not just the executive committee working on this, but to put a task force together of key people that are going to really push this um and kind of make the action steps kind of move with with a with an intentional strategy because um this is a a heavy lift, and and really what ended up being was that the the task force was about 40 to 50, a lot of them were practice owners, some were um professors, um, some were educators, um, some were weren’t even PTs, but they were um involved with contracts with other local health organizations um that would be ripple effects would be would be uh influenced by these changes as well. Um and so one of the the key things we did is we started to develop on the APTA Washington website a toolkit, we called it, where you don’t have to be a member, but anybody can go there, patients can go there, providers, HR departments, and we had templated letters. We had the emails that we were able to get for all of the premier leadership. Um and and so we had all this information there for um for providers, for clinic owners, and we had scripted scripted kind of templated um letters, you know, for a clinic owner, so the clinic order could actually put in like, okay, if if this goes through, this is what it’s going to, this is this is what it’s gonna cost me, and this is what I’m gonna have to. We were really clear on educating everybody, the antitrust laws of collusion, no boycotting. I mean, it’s there there’s a really there’s guardrails here of what you can and cannot say, and and I I will be I’m I’m very proud of how our association tackled that because that was you know kind of in the back of our minds through every step, making sure we were doing things the right way. Um then we got uh Alice Bell from APTA uh national, uh, who’s uh you know with the a VP of uh uh payment policy. She was uh helped us with strategy. Justin Moore um helped us as well with uh some strategy on some of the technical aspects of uh being able to craft some letters and send letters. Um and then we really we had task force meetings every four or every two weeks, and we just provided updates on what we were doing and what the next push was and what we were emphasizing. We um had social media videos, and I think when it when it came down to you know, we we really wanted the uh insurance commissioner to we really wanted their help on this because we just felt like we were we were getting screwed with with this how MPPR affected um physical therapy. Um but what we found is the insurance commissioner kind of looks at the you know, did they did did did the insurance company follow the um the the ways that they can inform members? Did they give enough notice and all those things they they did? Um but the insurance commissioner does not want to get involved, or even legislators we found, does not want to get involved with battles of payment and reimbursement between commercial payers and providers. That’s just they they don’t they don’t want to get in involved with that. But what they do care about is access to care for for networks and also for um Medicare and Medicaid patients. So. Tiffany Warden: 40:42 Yeah, I I like that. I 100% agree. You you cannot let the the in the commercial insurers run the narrative on this, because if you do, you you’ve lost already, and you do have to speak to how it’s going to affect uh uh patient access, it’s how it’s going to affect um businesses in the state and things like that. You always have to tie it back to something that’s of interest to whatever body you’re addressing. And I too, number two, I love the address of the idea of a toolbox toolkit that you’ve created. I don’t think there’s enough cooperation and communication between the state APTAs uh groups. Um, I think more cooperation between those groups, more communication would be something that would benefit us because, as you just said, you found this out in September and it was a go on December 4th. Well, there’s that 90 days that almost every contract says, Well, we can say anything we want, and in 90 days it can become effective, and you don’t have to sign anything, we’ll just tell you that’s their notice up period. That doesn’t give anybody uh a lot of time to organize, um, to organize a group of people, to organize a group of workers, a message, materials. It doesn’t give anybody that. So having a toolkit and having a little bit more cooperation, I think, between the state uh APTA groups would really benefit us um in our ability to, as an industry, push back against against some of these cuts. Richard Leaver: 42:08 I think what what has to happen, what happened in Washington, uh, and happened in other states as well, is there has to be a certain noise level. And that noise uh has to be from multiple stakeholders as well. So as you said, really the practitioner uh is perhaps one of the least important in uh with the stakeholder in this um communicating to the commercial payers. It tends to be the members, uh perhaps physician groups, employers absolutely that are self-insured, etc. But it has to reach a level of noise in which it becomes uh visible to senior leadership within those commercial payers and also create a level of discomfort and potential risk that they cannot ignore. Um and you know, sometimes there’s success and sometimes not. In the past, I don’t think there was necessarily the level of noise to even get onto the radar, and that’s what they that’s what they actually uh hoped for, and then they would just quietly push through these these uh changes and either administrative changes or reimbursement changes that would be adversely impact us. Um so and general awareness, I always feel that the profession actually over the last few years has done much better with regards to advocacy general. So not only you actually were you pushing within Washington APTA, APTQI, and all the members were also pushing as well, which is a huge uh group of clinic group and uh block of outpatient therapy. So you would you the state certainly wasn’t alone, and perhaps actually uh as part member of that task force, you probably actually didn’t see or hear of that uh being done. uh uh in addition to what you were doing because of this fragmentation that we have about patient therapy but but behind the scenes there was a lot of a lot of conversations and a a lot of communications from multiple stakeholders um so that that that worked well in this instance. Alliance Physical Therapy Partners: 44:23 Selling your practice doesn’t have to mean ending your career. At Alliance Physical Therapy Partners, we strive to empower practice owners and their teams by allowing them to focus on the jobs they do best. Keep your brand name, retain control where you want it, and reduce your overhead costs. On top of that, enjoy access to industry leading benefits, new technology, leadership growth opportunities, and so much more. Partner with Alliance and explore the future of your practice. Visit allianceptp.com and click on Let’s Be Partners to learn more. Richard Leaver: 44:59 um any final thoughts we’re running out of time uh anything else that perhaps either takeaways uh anything that you feel that practice owners clinic directors or PTs need to be aware of to to do uh as it pertains to kind of the MPPR and the potential uh escalation of this within the commercial payer world so mark any final comments thoughts? Mark Bouma: 45:31 Yeah I mean I think this is at least for us in Washington this is a little bit of a sigh of relief or a pause just for a moment but you know we this is a battle that we won but we’re still fighting the war but I if you win a lot of battles then you you you have a good chance of winning the war so I think we just take it one battle at a time but what really what this this highlighted to me is um uh you know just it’s complete engaged grassroots advocacy and volume matters per you know being persistent and consistent with your message matters and you know we did lean on some of the leaders at APTA national and they um um and they really supported us uh 100% um which was phenomenal and um just a quick update to the listeners too um this insurance company we we for last month we were asking to actually sit down and have a conversation to explain what they were missing about the practice expense um aspect of this and they just crickets we they didn’t they didn’t even acknowledge our request to to meet um yesterday um the lobbyist for the insurance company contacted apt washington lobbyist and they want to sit down and have a conversation so um we’ll be scheduling that in the next week or two and we’ll have Alice Bell and Justin Moore and a few of the other key leaders in uh APT Washington to actually sit down and have a dialogue which that’s that’s surprising I so so so we’ll see kind of where that goes we’ll have some preparation for that but um you know again I think that uh I’m super proud of what all of our engaged members um have been able to to do and and also just educating our front offices and our patients about the issue so that they can they can funnel their complaints to um to to the right people quickly and without as much with with as little friction as possible. Richard Leaver: 47:24 So, Tiffany? Tiffany Warden: 47:27 My final words are are what we already do uh know your contracts know what those terms are know what those notice periods are and check those payer portals check the you know make sure you’re keeping up with the payer communications you’re you’re subscribed to whatever feed you need to be subscribed to so that you’re getting notifications and you don’t uh miss any period of time uh that you would have to respond to something that doesn’t correspond with your company’s best interests Richard Leaver: 47:56 Well thank you both so much for your time today uh I know it’s not necessarily the most exciting a topic but actually I’ve learned a lot and uh it is uh a profoundly important topic at the current time and congrats uh for the uh for your task force in Washington Mark obviously it made an impact and certainly sets a roadmap for when other commercial players uh try to do it in other states which I’m sure they will so thank you both. Tiffany Warden: 48:26 Thank you for having us! Mark Bouma: 48:27 Thank you. Alliance Physical Therapy Partners: 48:28 This has been another episode of the PT Leadership Podcast brought to you by Alliance Physical Therapy Partners. Learn more about our team and find more episodes online at alliance ptp.com / podcast  

When Was Your Appointment?

We recently changed bill pay providers. Please click the button for the date of your appointment to be directed to the correct online payment portal.